Another major exception is when a team is short-handed. A team trying to eliminate a penalty (commonly known as a "penalty kill") may legally "ice the puck". The opposing team on a power play, however, must still follow the icing rules.
When icing occurs, a linesman stops play. Play is resumed with a faceoff in the defending zone of the attacking team, who committed the infraction. If there is a delayed penalty, it will happen at the attacking team's neutral spot. If the linesman erred in stopping play for icing, the faceoff is at the centre face-off spot (unless there is a delayed penalty).
|No penalty||Delayed penalty|
|Correct||defending spot of attacking team||neutral spot of attacking team|
|Error||centre spot (except USA Hockey)||defending spot of defending team|
|defending spot of defending team (USA Hockey)|
The icing rule has three variations:
- touch icing
- no-touch or automatic icing
- hybrid icing
In touch icing, a player on the opposing team other than the goaltender must touch the puck to cause the stoppage of play. If the puck is first touched by the goaltender or a player on the team that iced the puck, icing is waved off (cancelled) and play continues. The icing rule can lead to high-speed races for the puck. While an icing call is pending, the linesman raises an arm to indicate that a potential icing call may be made. If the icing is waved off, the official lowers his arm and gives the washout signal (extending both arms sideways from the body at shoulder height, similar to the "safe" sign in baseball but typically delivered from a less-crouched or fully upright position).
No-touch or automatic icing
Most amateur leagues worldwide use no-touch or automatic icing, where play is stopped for icing immediately once the puck crosses the goal line.
International IIHF rules, the National Hockey League, American Hockey League, NCAA college hockey, European professional leagues, and several minor North American leagues (ECHL, Central Hockey League and SPHL) use hybrid icing. Play is stopped immediately if the player on the opposing team reaches the faceoff dot first, instead of skating all the way across the goal line to touch the puck. This type of icing is intended to reduce the number of collisions along the boards during touch icing, but still allowing the team that iced the puck to get to it first to wave off the icing. In instances where the puck is shot around the end boards, travels down the ice and comes out the other end, the linesman has to determine who would have touched the puck first. If it's the defending player, he calls an automatic icing, but if it's the attacking player he lets the play continue.
The NHL adopted the hybrid icing variation as its rule beginning with the 2013–14 season, after several decades of using touch icing.
The IIHF adopted the hybrid icing rule in 2014 after a few decades of using no-touch icing.
Icing is always waved off in the following situations:
- The team committing the icing is shorthanded, i.e. penalty killing (except under USA Hockey rules in competitions for 14-and-under age groups).
- The linesman believes a player on the opposing team (other than the goaltender) could have played the puck before it crossed the goal line.
- The puck enters the goal.
- The puck is iced directly from a player participating in a face-off.
- The goaltender leaves his goal crease and moves in the direction of the puck (except under USA Hockey rules).
The National Hockey League (NHL) introduced the icing rule in September 1937 to eliminate a common delaying tactic used by teams to protect a winning margin. A November 18, 1931 game between the New York Americans and Boston Bruins is cited as one extreme example that led to the ban on the practice. The Americans, protecting a 3–2 lead over the Bruins at Boston Garden, iced the puck over 50 times. The crowd became incensed and threw debris onto the ice, causing a delay while the teams were sent to their dressing rooms. When the teams met again that December 3 in New York, the Bruins iced the puck 87 times in a scoreless draw.
The rule was amended in June 1951 to state the icing infraction was nullified if the goaltender touched the puck. For the 1990–91 season, the league again amended the rule, stating the infraction was nullified if the puck passed through or touched the goal crease when the goaltender had been removed for an extra attacker. The NHL amended the rule a third time; icing was nullified if the goaltender moved towards the puck as it approached the goal line.
The 1970s-era World Hockey Association (WHA) never adopted the NHL rule of allowing shorthanded teams to ice the puck. In 2009, USA Hockey considered eliminating the shorthanded icing rule, having tested its elimination in Massachusetts and Alaska in the 2007-2009 seasons.
The IIHF adopted the no-touch icing rule after an incident in the Czechoslovak First Ice Hockey League in 1990, when Luděk Čajka, rushing to get to the puck in an icing situation, crashed into the boards, suffered severe spinal injuries, and died a few weeks later.
After some teams in need of a line change (player substitution) began deliberately icing the puck to stop play, and as part of a group of important rule changes following the 2004–05 NHL lockout, the NHL supplemented the icing rule prior to the 2005–06 season by not allowing the offending team to substitute players before the next faceoff, except to replace an injured player, when the goaltender must return to the net following an icing call. This change was made in an effort to speed up game play by reducing icing infractions, as well as to encourage teams to work the puck up the ice rather than taking the opportunity to rest their players. In some junior leagues (such as the WHL), the offending team is permitted to substitute players after an icing only if the puck was shot from the neutral zone (between the defensive blue line and the red line). If the violation occurs in the defensive zone, substitution is prohibited. Regardless, in all situations, if icing is called, and then a penalty is assessed that changes the on-ice strength of either team (from 5 on 5 to 5 on 4, et al.), the offending team may substitute.
On June 13, 2017, USA Hockey adopted a rule change which eliminated the shorthanded icing exception. The rule change establishes that when a shorthanded team ices the puck a subsequent icing infraction will be enforced; play will stop and a face off will occur in the offending team's zone. The rule change is effective starting with the 2017–18 regular season, impacting 14U and younger age groups.
Starting with the 2017–18 NHL season, offending teams are not allowed to take a timeout after an icing. In the 2019–20 NHL season a rule change allowed the offensive team to decide at which end zone dot they wished the face-off to be held following an icing  (intended to grant a positional advantage to teams stronger on a certain side).
- Basic Ice Hockey Rules
- SECTION 4 – PLAYING RULES – Page 45
- Under USA Hockey Rules (Rule 624(c), if the Officials shall have erred in calling an “icing the puck” infraction (regardless of whether either team is shorthanded) a face-off shall occur not at center ice, but at the end zone faceoff spot nearest to the location of the puck when play was stopped. https://cdn2.sportngin.com/attachments/document/59e7-1650960/2017-21_USAH_Rulebook.pdf?_ga=2.207262554.899721225.1556063714-515831901.1556063713
- "Rule 624 | Icing the Puck". usahockeyrulebook.com. Retrieved 2019-01-12.
- "New rules approved". IIHF. May 24, 2014. Archived from the original on 2014-07-05. Retrieved 2014-07-18.
- "Hybrid icing approved by players, will be in effect for 2013–14 season". CBS Sports. September 30, 2013. Retrieved 2013-10-23.
- Duplacey 1996, p. 131.
- Duplacey 1996, pp. 130–131.
- "Icing Rule Ready For Heated Debate," USA Hockey Magazine. Accessed 2010-02-07.
- "A look at the NHL's new rules", NBC Sports Archived 2009-07-17 at the Wayback Machine. Accessed 2009-05-18
- NHL announces rule changes for 2019-20 season