|North American tour by Hole and Marilyn Manson|
Promotional poster for the March 11, 1999 performance of the Beautiful Monsters Tour
|Location||United States and Canada|
|Associated album||Celebrity Skin and Mechanical Animals|
|Start date||February 28, 1999|
|End date||March 14, 1999|
|No. of shows|
The Beautiful Monsters Tour was a North American concert tour co-headlined by American rock bands Hole and Marilyn Manson. Launched in support of each band's respective third full-length studio LPs, 1998's Celebrity Skin and Mechanical Animals,[N 1] the tour was planned to run from February 28, 1999 until April 27, with 37 shows confirmed. However, due to a highly publicized altercation between the bands' respective lead vocalists, the tour only visited arenas until March 14, for a total of 9 shows before Hole withdrew from the bill. The tour garnered a large amount of media attention and was billed by MTV as a "potentially volatile mix" due to the public feud between each band's outspoken vocalist.
The co-headlining tour was conceived by Hole's management company, Q Prime. Hole singer Courtney Love teased the press that she aimed to launch a tour with Canadian singer-songwriter Alanis Morissette. However, Hole's management aggressively pursued Marilyn Manson's eponymous band, even amid a public feud stemming from Manson's depiction of Love in his autobiography The Long Hard Road Out of Hell. Nevertheless, the groups agreed to tour together provided that costs and revenue were split 50/50.
The tour was marred by on–and–off stage exchanges between Love and Manson, as well as private disputes over the tour's financial arrangements, which resulted in Hole unwittingly financing most of Manson's production costs which was disproportionately higher relative to their own. After Hole left, Marilyn Manson continued the tour under the name Rock Is Dead. Marilyn Manson released two recordings that documented portions of the tour: a live video album titled God Is in the T.V. and a live album titled The Last Tour on Earth. Love and Manson finally reconciled their differences in 2015, more than 15 years after the end of the tour.
Background and development
Plans for a joint tour were conceived by Hole's management company, Q Prime, during the band's stint at the 1999 Big Day Out music festival in Australia in order to support their third studio album Celebrity Skin. Hole guitarist Eric Erlandson admitted that the band itself had "anxiously been awaiting" their first full-scale U.S. tour for some time, but their previous attempts "kept falling apart because we couldn't find someone to tour with". Erlandson said he was "just psyched to hit the road with anybody". Hole frontwoman Courtney Love toyed with the idea of touring with Canadian pop rock singer-songwriter Alanis Morissette in the press. During an interview on Los Angeles radio station KROQ-FM, Love claimed her opinions on Morissette had changed. She had previously maligned Morissette's pop work as being "too commercial [for Morissette] to ever be considered a genuine feminist symbol". Nevertheless, Love, who was one of the most prominent and prolific figures of feminist music in the 1990s, began to see Morissette as a positive influence on female empowerment.
—Excerpt of an insult Marilyn Manson gave at the expense of Love during an interview before the tour. The quote was in response to the closing lyrics of the New Radicals song "You Get What You Give", wherein both singers were pilloried.
In 1998 and 1999, Love and rock singer Marilyn Manson were engaged in a highly publicized feud and regularly traded insults with each other in the press. Love took offense to Manson's depiction of her in his autobiography The Long Hard Road Out of Hell.[N 2] In spite of their disagreement, Hole's management aggressively pursued a joint tour with Manson's eponymous rock band. Manson was initially reluctant to accept the offer. He had reservations about Love, whom he pejoratively described in an interview with NME as "an opportunist" who he felt tried to exploit his band's new-found fame to bolster hers. He noted that Love never attempted to befriend him until he had sold a million records.[N 3] Love also voiced her concerns about touring with Manson, whose explicit stage shows, she felt, were potentially deleterious to her young daughter, Frances Bean. Despite their mutual hostility, Manson accepted the offer to support his band's own third studio album. He joked that he agreed to the tour because he realized "what better role models to lead the youth of America into the new millennium than us two? So it had to be done".
During their negotiations, both sides agreed that the opening act from the inaugural show until their scheduled performance on April 4 in Philadelphia would be Manson's option, stoner rock band Monster Magnet. A dispute arose on who would take over. According to Erlandson and Hole bassist Melissa Auf der Maur, the two groups had a two-hour meeting to arrive at a resolution. Manson and his band voted for early 1980s Britpop groups like Fun Boy Three and Fine Young Cannibals, while members of Hole wanted "more modern" bands. Auf der Maur noted that "we want romance and they want theater. We want love and they want shtick. We had to explain to them that those kinds of bands make them look good, but us look silly". Eventually, Manson's band ceded the selection of the subsequent opening act to Love, who chose Imperial Teen. During their negotiations, both bands agreed to split the production cost and revenue earned at each show 50/50.
Promotion and naming
Love officially announced Manson's attachment to the tour on January 6, 1999 by phoning in to the MTV show Total Request Live. She told host Carson Daly, "Yeah, Brian [real name of frontman Marilyn Manson] wants it", claiming that the two had reconciled and had mutual admiration. She also confirmed the lineup for each respective date on the tour. The tour was scheduled to begin on February 28, 1999 with 37 dates confirmed, spanning a total of 8 weeks. Tickets retailed for $30 and the concerts were to be hosted at 10,000-20,000 capacity venues.
The name "Beautiful Monsters" was fashioned by Auf der Maur as an acknowledgement of both band's roots in dark, angry and abrasive alternative rock music, and their transformation in sound and appearance for each of their respective third albums. The allusion also extended to the polarity between each group's approach to the change. Both bands undertook an evolution of their sound overseen by the same producer, Michael Beinhorn. Whereas Hole opted for an alternative pop update of the California sound in the L.A. tradition of bands like The Doors, The Beach Boys and The Byrds, Manson shifted to hedonistic 1970's glam rock inspired by David Bowie, T. Rex and Gary Glitter. Auf der Maur thought it "a perfect complement. We bring on the light after they've dragged out the dark. It's two different worlds, so I can't see how one could make the other look bad. Theirs is black and ours is white."
The tour was covered extensively by MTV who anticipated it being a "potentially volatile mix". They noted the "strange juxtaposing" of two bands whose extremely outspoken lead vocalists were engaged in a public row.
—Marilyn Manson on why he joined the tour
The feud between Love and Manson carried over into their shows immediately after the tour began. They traded nightly exchanges of thinly-veiled insults during their respective sets. MTV also noted the extreme difference between both band's production, set design and use of special effects. Hole opted for a minimal set design consisting of a projected backdrop and a series of garlands draped across the monitors and drum kit. Their special effects were limited to occasional use of a pressurized cannon that projected an explosion of glitter during their performance of the song "Dying", and a rain of rose petals that were dropped from the rafters onto the stage during the song "Celebrity Skin". Manson's performance, by contrast, utilized expensive pyrotechnics, elaborate props and set pieces as well as numerous costume changes. Much to Love's chagrin, the majority of concertgoers were Manson fans who were less interested in the Hole performance.
The tour commenced, as scheduled, on February 28, 1999 at the Spokane Arena in Spokane, Washington. MTV reported that the inaugural show only sold 8,500 tickets, less than half of the arena's 18,000-person capacity. Monster Magnet's opening slot lasted 45 minutes and, as noted by MTV, displayed "the same energy that made them a hit on Rob Zombie's last US tour". During Hole's performance, Love joked with the audience between songs. She also gave away two guitars and her boots to audience members. However, Hole left the stage after only 45 minutes into their show (out of a scheduled hour and a half set) due to Love's disappointment with the audience turnout. Marilyn Manson was due to perform after Hole's scheduled exit from the stage, but started 90 minutes late due to problems that arose from having to construct their complicated theatrics in a rush after Hole's impromptu walkout.[N 4] After the problems were resolved, they played an hour and a half show marked by deliberate destruction of their instruments and explicit onstage antics that were the band's trademark. They ended the show with a performance of their signature song "The Beautiful People" followed by an encore.[N 5]
Two incidents occurred at the tour's second stop at the PNE Coliseum on March 2, 1999 in Vancouver, Canada. After Manson made a lewd remark about Love during his band's performance, Love ran onstage, hiked her dress and jumped on Manson's back while he sang. Later in the show, Manson suffered from dizziness and fainted onstage, injuring his hand on a monitor as he fell. Initially he pretended it was part of the show, but left the stage after performing their signature song to seek medical attention. When he returned onstage, he pulled the plugs off of their instrument amplifiers and stormed offstage without performing an encore. The rest of the band left the stage afterward.
The Seattle show on March 3, 1999 at the KeyArena included Manson's then-fiancée Rose McGowan and Pearl Jam frontman Eddie Vedder in the audience. It was also a homecoming concert for Hole. Love had mixed feelings about returning to Seattle, which was where she and her late husband Kurt Cobain settled to start their family shortly before he committed suicide in 1994. It was also the epicenter of the grunge music scene and close to the riot grrrl scene of nearby Olympia, Washington, genres with which Hole were often misidentified during its early history. On the return to Seattle, Love lightheartedly quipped:
"Grunge is dead. Grunge is over, okay everyone? I'm here, and we're here to soothe [things] and to help everyone move through this. And it was like the grunge receptacle."
Press speculation on Hole's departure from the tour began on March 11, 1999 the day after the tour's sixth show at the Cow Palace in Daly City, California. Manson had renamed the tour "Hole is Dead" on his official website as a taunt which exacerbated conjecture. He also prefaced the show with an interview in the San Francisco Chronicle who asked him jokingly if any cows were going to be sacrificed during the concert. He facetiously remarked, "well ... there's always Courtney".
During the concert, Love polled the audience as to whether or not they wanted her band to continue performing. After the audience responded encouragingly, she derided both Manson's use of pyrotechnics and the audience's expectations of a decadent spectacle, then justified Hole's performance approach as musically-focused.[N 6] Manson initially resisted responding to Love's criticism during his band's turn on stage. However, after the band performed their single "The Dope Show", Manson retorted by holding his own poll, asking how much of the audience were there to watch his band. After the majority of concertgoers erupted in a loud cheer he taunted, "I show pity for the older people on this tour ... the graying mothers" in reference to Love.
The next day, Manson issued a statement on his website that apologized for his band's inability to attend the post-show after-party due to "extreme problems being caused by Hole". He acknowledged the existence of "a war between us and Hole", and predicted that the latter would not be a part of the tour for much longer. Love also spoke to MTV and cited serious production issues as the cause of the rift. She confirmed that she and her band seriously considered leaving the tour but that both bands would meet over the weekend ahead of the March 14, 1999 performance at The Forum in Inglewood, California to discuss their concerns and resolve their conflict.
Less than a day after Love announced the probability of her band leaving the tour, DJ Bill Abbate of Boston-based radio station WCBN FM read a press release issued by Cambridge, Massachusetts-based tour promoter Don Law Concert Promotions, stating that Hole had already withdrawn from the double bill. The release was sent to several alternative rock radio stations in the Boston area. Hole spokesperson Gayle Fine and Don Law public relations director Pamela Fallon challenged the announcement. Fine did not guarantee that Hole would be on the tour after March 14, 1999, but she assured ticket holders that the band would perform at the March 13, 1999 concert at The Pond and The Forum. News of Hole's possible departure put the future of the tour into question among industry experts. Industry trade publication Pollstar's editor-in-chief Gary Bongiovanni commented, "Historically, Manson has gotten arena-level press but not sold-out arenas."
On March 14, 1999, Hole officially announced their withdrawal from the tour as they took the stage at The Forum arena. Love cited public ridicule as well as the inability of the two groups to resolve the financial issues related to Manson's expensive production among their reasons. Due to their 50/50 arrangement, Hole inadvertently subsidized a huge portion of the large cost of mounting Manson's shows which depleted their revenue. At their final performance, Love told the audience, "We're history after this. You'll get to see the crack of someone's ass (a reference to Manson's habit of dropping his pants onstage). It will be fun." During their performance later in the evening, Manson suffered a hairline fracture on one of his ankles while jumping between on-stage platforms. His injury caused the tour to be temporarily suspended.
Following their departure, Hole had a series of shows in North America and the United Kingdom. They joined the British Glastonbury Festival in Pilton, Somerset, England on June 22, 1999 and performed two shows with the female-focused music festival Lilith Fair on August 10, 1999 at the Polaris Amphitheater in Columbus, Ohio and August 11, 1999 at the Riverbend Music Center in Cincinnati, respectively. Marilyn Manson resumed the tour on March 21, 1999, renaming it the Rock Is Dead Tour after their single "Rock Is Dead", despite the fact that the name was already being used by American rock bands Korn and Rob Zombie for their own concurrent joint U.S. tour. Manson kept all of the remaining scheduled engagements intact.
Imperial Teen's billing was withdrawn in favor of Grammy-nominated American psychobilly band Nashville Pussy, who took over the opening act slot from Monster Magnet beginning from the April 2, 1999 concert at the Memorial Coliseum in Winston-Salem, North Carolina until the completion of all North American dates on the tour. Manson explained to MTV that the initial inclusion of Imperial Teen on the tour was "by Courtney's request. I think we're probably better off, because that would've been an additional torment for our fans that they didn't need." He added that while he enjoyed their music on CD, he felt there was too much difference in their musical and performance approach for their continued inclusion on the tour to work.
Marilyn Manson released a live video album on November 2, 1999 titled God Is in the T.V., which contained unreleased footage including a behind-the-scenes backstage look at some of the experiences the band underwent during the Beautiful Monsters Tour. He claimed it clarified the real motive for Hole's departure. He added, "There's a really great speech [Love] gives about me and her insecurity and lack of fans at the concerts. Although it disparages her somewhat, I find it very amusing." He also released a live album on November 12, 1999 titled The Last Tour on Earth that documented curated performances by his band from various concerts during the tour.
More than 15 years after the tour ended, Love and Manson settled their differences and reconciled. In December 2014, Love posted a picture on the social networking service Instagram of her, Manson and their mutual friend Billy Corgan[N 7] sitting together with a caption that read "all hatchets buried". In an interview with Esquire magazine on January 20, 2015, Manson elaborated on their reconciliation[N 8] which prompted a sarcastic response from Love on the social networking service Twitter.[N 9] In 2018, Love made a cameo appearance as a nurse in Manson's video for "Tattooed in Reverse".
- Vocals, guitar: Courtney Love
- Guitar: Eric Erlandson
- Bass, backing vocals: Melissa Auf der Maur
- Drums, percussions: Samantha Maloney
|28 February 1999||Spokane||United States||Spokane Arena||Monster Magnet|
|2 March 1999||Vancouver||Canada||PNE Coliseum|
|3 March 1999||Seattle||United States||KeyArena|
|6 March 1999||Portland||Rose Garden Arena|
|7 March 1999||Nampa||Idaho Center|
|10 March 1999||Daly City||Cow Palace|
|11 March 1999||Sacramento||ARCO Arena|
|13 March 1999||Anaheim||The Pond|
|14 March 1999||Inglewood||The Forum|
- Both albums also shared the same record producer, Michael Beinhorn.
- In the book, Manson alleged that Love "manipulatively" began a sexual relationship with Twiggy Ramirez as a means of "keeping tabs" on her former boyfriend, Trent Reznor.
- Complete statement: "Courtney never bothered to say hi to me until I sold a million records. She's an opportunist and I wouldn't consider her a friend ... the way she's behaved towards me in the media has seemed very exploitative. I'm not interested in being anything to her".
- Some examples of Marilyn Manson's complex stage props: 1.) During performances of "The Reflecting God" from their 1996 album Antichrist Superstar, Manson would appear onstage affixed to a large crucifix made of television sets that rose out of the ground. He would climb out and begin performing. Near the end of the song the TV crucifix was regularly set ablaze. 2.) During performances of "I Don't Like The Drugs (But The Drugs Like Me)" from Mechanical Animals, the band performed while a large Hollywood-style sign flashed the word 'DRUGS' behind them.
- The encore consisted of "Coma White" and their rendition of Patti Smith's song "Rock N Roll Nigger"
- Courtney Love: "I guess you're sort of waiting for the pyrotechnics show. We don't know how to do fire and stuff. We're just a rock 'n' roll band, you little shits ... We're sort of all about the music."
- Lead singer of American alternative rock band The Smashing Pumpkins. Corgan contributed largely to the songwriting process on Celebrity Skin and acted as a musical consultant on Mechanical Animals.
- Extract from Marilyn Manson's Esquire magazine interview titled, Marilyn Manson on 'Inventing' Grunge, Sons of Anarchy, and Why He's a Furby: "We never really had a falling out. We've always been weird with each other, because she's slept with pretty much every one of my friends, supposedly. Not me, though. She, one time, told me she was mad at me because I didn't want to fuck her and I was smarter than her. I said, "Well, you kind of proved your own point right there on that one." But it was cool. We didn't work any scenes together (on American television series Sons of Anarchy), but I saw her on the red carpet. Her dress broke, and I said, "You okay? Your pussy didn't show, did it?" and she said, "No", and I went, "Thank God! That would've been horrible!" That was the only time I fucked with her. Other than that, I'm cool with Courtney."
- Love's Twitter response to Manson's Esquire interview: "Omg @marilynmanson all this time thought u're gay. Of course I'll fuck u. Im free Fri from 1:15 to 1:18 gives us plenty time 4 a smoke too x"
- Kaufman, Gil (1999-01-27). "Marilyn Manson, Hole Schedule 'Beautiful Monsters' Tour". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. Archived from the original on 2015-07-27. Retrieved 2015-07-06.
- "Courtney Love Considers Manson, Morissette Tours As Hole Gets Six CMA Nods". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1998-12-02. Archived from the original on 2015-07-26. Retrieved 2015-07-05.
- Kaufman, Gil (1998-03-12). "Best Of '99: Boston Promoter Says Hole Dropping Off Manson Tour". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. Archived from the original on 2016-03-17. Retrieved 2015-07-16.
- "New Radicals Discuss Slighting Marilyn Manson And Courtney Love, Manson Responds". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1998-12-02. Archived from the original on 2015-07-31. Retrieved 2015-07-06.
- "Hole Walks Out On Tour, Manson Injury Postpones Several Dates". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-03-15. Archived from the original on 2014-12-20. Retrieved 2015-07-05.
- Manson & Strauss 1998, pp. 255.
- MTV News Staff (January 21, 1998). "Manson Book Tells Tales Of Navarro, Love, Reznor". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. Archived from the original on January 22, 2018. Retrieved January 22, 2018.
- Kaufman, Gil (1999-03-11). "Hole Threaten To Drop Off Marilyn Manson Joint Tour". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. Archived from the original on 2015-07-28. Retrieved 2015-07-07.
- "Marilyn Manson, Hole Announce Two Months Worth Of Dates". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-01-27. Archived from the original on 2015-07-26. Retrieved 2015-07-05.
- "Manson Resumes Tour Without Hole, Taps Nashville Pussy And Jack Off Jill For Upcoming Dates". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-03-22. Archived from the original on 2016-05-15. Retrieved 2011-03-07.
- "Marilyn Manson Says Hole's Departure From Tour "Not A Personal Thing"". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-03-15. Archived from the original on 2014-12-20. Retrieved 2011-03-07.
- "Courtney Talks About Hole/Manson Tour". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-01-07. Archived from the original on 2015-07-26. Retrieved 2015-07-05.
- The Interview (CD). Hole. Geffen. 1998. PRO-CD-1232.CS1 maint: others (link)
- "Manson, Hole Get Tour On The Road". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-03-02. Archived from the original on 2015-07-26. Retrieved 2015-07-06.
- "Marilyn Manson Falls For Vancouver". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-03-04. Archived from the original on 2015-08-09. Retrieved 2015-07-16.
- "Hole, Marilyn Manson Avoid Nostalgia As Tour Rolls Into Seattle". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-03-05. Archived from the original on 2015-07-26. Retrieved 2011-03-07.
- Moran, Caitlin (1999-09-01). "The Girl Who Wanted To Be God". Select. Ascential plc: 92.
- Paul, Brannigan (October 2003). "All-American Reject". Kerrang!. No. 977. Bauer Media Group. pp. 24–27. ISSN 0262-6624.
- "All's Fair in Love". NME. Time Inc. UK. 1999-04-18. Archived from the original on 2015-07-15. Retrieved 2015-07-15.
- "Hole To Play A Pair Of Lilith Dates". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-05-28. Archived from the original on 2015-08-08. Retrieved 2015-07-15.
- "Hole Playing Two Lilith Shows". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-05-28. Archived from the original on 2015-08-08. Retrieved 2015-07-15.
- "Marilyn Manson Talks Rock Survival As Tour With Hole Marches On". MTV. Viacom Media Networks. 1999-03-10. Archived from the original on 2015-07-26. Retrieved 2015-07-14.
- "Manson: Love Hate Hate Love". NME. Time Inc. UK. 1999-05-28. Archived from the original on 2015-07-15. Retrieved 2015-07-15.
- Kreps, Daniel (2014-12-06). "Courtney Love, Billy Corgan and Marilyn Manson Mend Longstanding Rift". Rolling Stone. Jann Wenner. Archived from the original on 2016-05-07. Retrieved 2015-07-15.
- Carley, Brennan (2015-01-21). "Marilyn Manson Claims Courtney Love Got Mad That He Wouldn't Sleep With Her". Spin. Valence Media. Archived from the original on 2015-08-02. Retrieved 2015-07-15.
- Thompson, Barry (2015-01-20). "Marilyn Manson on 'Inventing' Grunge, Sons of Anarchy, and Why He's a Furby". Esquire. Hearst Magazines. Archived from the original on 2016-06-20. Retrieved 2015-07-16.
- Mcrady, Rachel (2015-01-21). "Marilyn Manson: Courtney Love Slept With My Friends, Billy Corgan Warned Me Rose McGowan Would Ruin My Life". Us Weekly. American Media, Inc. Archived from the original on 2015-07-16. Retrieved 2015-07-16.
- Jones, Abby (2018-03-23). "Marilyn Manson Drops Bone-Chilling 'Tattooed In Reverse' Video With Courtney Love: Watch". Billboard. Prometheus Global Media. Retrieved 2018-03-26.
- Manson, Marilyn; Strauss, Neil (1998). The Long Hard Road Out of Hell. HarperCollins. ISBN 978-0-06-098746-6 – via Internet Archive.
- Schippers, Mimi A. (2002). Rockin' out of the Box: Gender Maneuvering in Alternative Hard Rock. New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press. p. 93. ISBN 978-0-8135-3075-8.