The 1958 College Football All-America team is composed of college football players who were selected as All-Americans by various organizations and writers that chose College Football All-America Teams in 1958. The six selectors recognized by the NCAA as "official" for the 1958 season are (1) the American Football Coaches Association (AFCA), (2) the Associated Press (AP), (3) the Football Writers Association of America (FWAA), (4) the Newspaper Enterprise Association (NEA), (5) the Sporting News, and (6) the United Press International (UPI).
Three players were unanimously chosen as first-team All-Americans by all six official selectors. They were: (1) quarterback Randy Duncan who won the 1958 Walter Camp Player of the Year Award and led the 1958 Iowa Hawkeyes to the 1958 FWAA national championship; (2) halfback Billy Cannon who led the 1958 LSU Tigers to the 1958 AP national championship and won the Heisman Trophy in 1959; and (3) Army halfback Pete Dawkins who won the 1958 Heisman Trophy and later became a Rhodes scholar, a brigadier general, co-chairman of Bain & Company, and CEO of Primerica. All three have been inducted into the College Football Hall of Fame.
For the year 1958, the NCAA recognizes six published All-American teams as "official" designations for purposes of its consensus determinations. The following chart identifies the NCAA-recognized consensus All-Americans and displays which first-team designations they received.
|Billy Cannon||Halfback||LSU||6/6||AFCA, AP, FWAA, NEA, SN, UPI||CP, Time, WC|
|Randy Duncan||Quarterback||Iowa||6/6||AFCA, AP, FWAA, NEA, SN, UPI||CP, WC|
|Pete Dawkins||Halfback||Army||6/6||AFCA, AP, FWAA, NEA, SN, UPI||CP, WC|
|Buddy Dial||End||Rice||5/6||AP, FWAA, NEA, SN, UPI||Time, WC|
|Ted Bates||Tackle||Oregon State||5/6||AFCA, AP, NEA, SN, UPI||CP, WC|
|Bob Harrison||Center||Oklahoma||5/6||AP, FWAA, NEA, SN, UPI||CP, WC|
|Bob White||Fullback||Ohio State||4/6||FWAA, NEA, SN, UPI||CP, Time, WC|
|John Guzik||Guard||Pittsburgh||4/6||FWAA, NEA, SN, UPI||Time, WC|
|Zeke Smith||Guard||Auburn||3/6||AP, FWAA, NEA||CP, Time, WC|
|George Deiderich||Guard||Vanderbilt||3/6||AP, AFCA, FWAA||--|
|Sam Williams||End||Michigan State||2/6||AFCA, UPI||Time, WC|
|Brock Strom||Tackle||Air Force||2/6||AP, UPI||WC|
All-American selections for 1958
- Buddy Dial, Rice (AP-1, FWAA, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, Time, WC)
- Sam Williams, Michigan State (AFCA, UPI-1, Time, WC)
- Jim Houston, Ohio State (AP-1, FWAA, NEA-2, UPI-3, CP)
- Al Goldstein, North Carolina (FWAA, NEA-1)
- Jim Wood, Oklahoma State (AFCA, AP-3)
- Curt Merz, Iowa (FWAA, NEA-2)
- Tom Franckhauser, Purdue (CP)
- Monty Stickles, Notre Dame (AP-2, SN, NEA-3, UPI-2)
- Carroll Dale, Virginia Tech (AP-2)
- Rich Kreitling, Illinois (AP-3, UPI-2)
- Jerry Wilson, Auburn (UPI-3)
- Chris Burford, Stanford (NEA-3)
- Ted Bates, Oregon State (AFCA, AP-1, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, CP, WC)
- Brock Strom, Air Force (AP-1, NEA-3, UPI-1, WC)
- Jim Marshall, Ohio State (SN, UPI-3, Time)
- Ron Luciano, Syracuse (AP-2, NEA-1, UPI-2, CP)
- Bill Leeka, UCLA (Time)
- Andy Cvercko, Northwestern (FWAA)
- Don Floyd, TCU (AP-2, FWAA, NEA-2, UPI-3)
- Vel Heckman, Florida (AP-3, FWAA, NEA-3, UPI-2)
- Gene Selawski, Purdue (AP-3, FWAA, NEA-2)
- Hogan Wharton, Houston (AFCA)
- John Guzik, Pittsburgh (AP-2, FWAA, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, Time, WC)
- Zeke Smith, Auburn (AP-1, FWAA, NEA-1, UPI-2, CP, Time, WC)
- George Deiderich, Vanderbilt (AP-1, AFCA, FWAA, NEA-2, UPI-2)
- Al Ecuyer, Notre Dame (UPI-1, CP, SN)
- Bob Novogratz, Army (AP-3, FWAA, NEA-2, UPI-3)
- John Wooten, Colorado (AFCA)
- Jerry Stalcup, Wisconsin (AP-2, NEA-3)
- Stan Renning, Montana (AP-3)
- Tom Koenig, SMU (UPI-3)
- George Fritzinger, Navy (NEA-3)
- Bob Harrison, Oklahoma (AP-1, FWAA, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, CP, WC)
- Jackie Burkett, Auburn (AFCA, AP-2, NEA-2, UPI-3, Time)
- Max Fugler, LSU (AP-3, FWAA, NEA-3, UPI-2)
- Randy Duncan, Iowa (AFCA, AP-1, FWAA, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, CP, WC)
- Joe Kapp, California (AP-3, FWAA, NEA-2, UPI-2, Time)
- Don Meredith, SMU (AP-2, FWAA, UPI-2)
- Tom Greene, Holy Cross (UPI-3)
- Billy Cannon, LSU (AFCA, AP-1, FWAA, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, CP, Time, WC)
- Pete Dawkins, Army (AFCA, AP-1, FWAA, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, CP, WC)
- Bob Anderson, Army (AP-2, FWAA, NEA-2, UPI-2)
- Dick Bass, Pacific (AP-2, NEA-2, UPI-2, Time)
- Ron Burton, Northwestern (AP-3)
- Alex Hawkins, South Carolina (AP-3)
- Dick Thornton, Northwestern (UPI-3)
- Jake Crouthamel, Dartmouth (NEA-3)
- Don Perkins, New Mexico (NEA-3)
- Bob White, Ohio State (AP-2, FWAA, NEA-1, SN, UPI-1, CP, Time, WC)
- Nick Pietrosante, Notre Dame (AFCA, AP-3, FWAA, NEA-2, UPI-3)
- Bill Austin, Rutgers (AP-1, UPI-3)
- Bob Jarus, Purdue (UPI-3)
- Fred Pickard, Florida State (NEA-3)
- Bold – Consensus All-American
- -1 – First-team selection
- -2 – Second-team selection
- -3 – Third-team selection
- AFCA = American Football Coaches Association
- AP = Associated Press
- FWAA = Football Writers Association of America
- NEA = Newspaper Enterprise Association
- SN = Sporting News
- UPI = United Press International
- CP = Central Press Association
- Time = Time magazine
- WC = Walter Camp Football Foundation
- 1958 All-Atlantic Coast Conference football team
- 1958 All-Big Eight Conference football team
- 1958 All-Big Ten Conference football team
- 1958 All-Pacific Coast Conference football team
- 1958 All-SEC football team
- 1958 All-Southwest Conference football team
- "Football Award Winners" (PDF). National Collegiate Athletic Association (NCAA). 2016. p. 9. Retrieved October 21, 2017.
- "Iowa's Randy Duncan Heads AP's All-American Team". Salisbury Times. Salisbury, Maryland.
- "Randy Hawkins Heads A.P. All-America Team". Reading Eagle. December 4, 1958. p. 34.
- Ted Gangi (ed.). "FWAA All-America Since 1944: The All-Time Team" (PDF). Retrieved February 8, 2015.
- Harry Grayson (ed.). "NEA Names Perkins Strom to 3rd Team". NEA.
- "SEC Places Smith, Cannon on All-America Team". Times Daily. November 30, 1958. p. 4T.
- "The Sporting News: College Football TSN All America Teams". The Sporting News. Archived from the original on 2009-07-27.
- "Ecuyer Of ND Listed". Tucson Daily Citizen.
- Leo Peterson (November 26, 1958). "Dawkins, Cannon Are Top A-A Picks". Beaver Valley Times.
- "Central Press All-American". New Castle News, New Castle, Pennsylvania.
- "Time All America Teams". Time, Inc.
- "All-America Teams". Walter Camp Football Foundation. Archived from the original on 2007-12-18.